Please read this list before suggesting a badge, it will save everyone time.
Teacher: Create 2+ tutorials.
Too much like Help Badge.
Creator: Create 10+ threads.
Waaaay too easy. At least the PG/EE/SR poll only happens a few times a year.
Insane Badge: Be insane.
Qualities are too subjective.
Elder/Elite Badge: Be a member for 2 or more years.
Redundant, we have the Vet Badge.
Page Jumper: Jump 150 pages.
WTF?
Demon Badge: Be smited 50+ times.
We do not reward bad behavior.
Full Email Badge: Get over 200 PMs from 50 different members.
Died off, but probably would've just been rejected.
SR/PG Fan Badge: Make 500+ posts in the SR or PG boards.
Impossible to track.
Dan-Ball Fan Badge: Make 2000+
Aren't we all Dan-Ball fans, seeing as, you know, we're the Dan-Ball Forum?
Participator: Participate in 5+ contests.
Died off, later replaced with cookie badges.
Uploader Badge: Upload x amounts of uploads with a total x+ votes.
The concepts were terrible, and it would be to hard to judge whether the upload actually deserved the badge.
Day and Night Badges: Post at 6PM and 6PM (18:00)
Too similar to Early Bird and Night Owl Badges.
Calligrapher: Have 25 posts only in Kanji.
Nobody wants to try to decipher Kanji posts into English.
Adviser Badge: Have 3+ ideas accepted in the EE or PG Request an Element/Non-Element threads.
Can be awarded through Ideas Badge.
Fake Badge: Have a fake badge in you sig and make someone as how you got it.
Too easy, and people can rig the system,
All Bades Badge: Earn every badge.
Once too hard, now it cannot be achieved due to the fact you cannot have all three Dan-Ball Game Badges.15 Badges Badge: Earn 15 Badges.
The #Badges are all factors of 10.
Typetacular Badge: Create 6 stories.
We already have a Book Badge.
Lost and Found Badge: Lose a file and later find it.
We have no way of proving this.
2000 Posts Badge: Post 2000 times.
We already have a post milestone.
Zombie Badge: Spend a disgusting amount of time on the forum.
Now way to prove it and most don't like being called zombies.
Normal Badge: Have 2+ mods think you're unusual.
Doesn't make sense, too subjective.
Backwards Thinking: Figure something out via reverse engineering.
Impossible to prove.
Necromancer: Necro-post 5 times a week. (You don't want this badge).
We don't reward negative behavior.
Dead Jokes: Kill a few jokes.
Why?
SHUTUP!: Create an unnecessarily long post.
Pointless, and too subjective.
Prodigal Badge: Leave for 6+ months and return.
We don't reward inactivity.
Power Badge: Have 10 people say that they would serve you.
Now this a perfect example of a truly ridiculous idea.
Cash Cow: Have 100k Dan-Balls.
Already have the 10k Dan-Ball Badge.
Hoarder: Don't spend any Dan-Balls for a month.
Way too easy.
Woo, that took an hour or so. Anyway, Badges that were suggested multiple times but were all rejected are listed as one badge.